Before beginning her coaching career, Reilly Gearhart was a student-athlete at La Salle University and West Chester University. At West Chester, she was awarded PSAC Pitcher of the Year in 2019 as well as helping her team advance to the College World Series. Since graduating from college, Reilly has been giving private pitching lessons, is the assistant coach for the 14u 09’s team, and is the Head Varsity Coach for her alma mater high school, Manheim Township.